Hypertrophic Vs Keloid Scars – Understanding the Difference

Not all scars heal in the same way. for some people, scars can become raised, thickened, and more noticeable over time. Two common types of raised scars are hypertrophic scars and keloid scars. While they may look similar at first, they behave quite differently.
Understanding the difference can help you recognise what's happening in your skin and explore appropriate treatment options if needed.
What Is a Hypertrophic Scar?
A hypertrophic scar is a raised scar that stays within the boundaries of the original wound.
Common Features:
- Red or pink in colour
- Raised and sometimes firm
- May feel slightly itchy or tight
- Develops relatively soon after the injury
- Often improves gradually over time
These scares are commonly seen after:
- Surgery
- Burns
- Cuts or injuries
What Is a Keloid Scar?
A keloid scar is a more complex type of scar that grows beyond the original wound area.
Common Features:
- Extends outside the original injury
- Can continue to grow over time
- Often darker than the surrounding skin
- May feel itchy, tender, or uncomfortable
- More likely to develop in certain areas such as the chest, shoulders, ears and upper back
Keloids are influenced by factors such as genetics and skin type.
Key Differences at a Glance
| Feature | Hypertrophic Scar | Keloid Scar |
|---|---|---|
| Growth area | Stays within wound | Extends beyond wound |
| Onset | Soon after injury | May develop later |
| Growth over time | May reduce | May continue growing |
| Appearance | Raised, red | Thicker, often darker |
Why Do These Scars Form?
Both hypertrophic and Keloid scars develop due to overproductions of collagen during the healing process.
- In hypertrophic scars, this overproduction tends to settle over time
- In keloid scars, the process continues beyond what is needed for healing
Can They Be Treated?
There are a range of options available depending on the type and severity of the scar.
Common approaches include:
- Silicone gels or sheets
- Massage and movements techniques
- Steroid injections (often used for keloids)
- Laser or medical treatments in some cases
The effectiveness of treatment can vary, particularly with the keloid scars, which can be more resistant and may require specialist care.
When to Seek Advice
You may want to explore treatment options if a scar:
- Is raised or continues to grow
- Feel itchy, painful, or tight
- Affect movement or comfort
- Causes concern aesthetically
Final Thoughts
Although hypertrophic and keloid scars can appear similar, they differ in how they grow and respond over time. Recognising these difference can help guide expectations and supports better decisions around care and treatment.